Do we Impose Too Many Rules on Our Children?
Society today pushes the importance of a good strong education, but rather than adding quality we seem to be adding quantity (more homework, more school days, longer school days and less recess). In my opinion this is incredibly unfair and unnatural. As a mother to two sons, I know this is not necessarily the best environment for boys to learn. They have oodles of energy and need an outlet to release their steam in order to be capable of behaving in a sit-down-and-listen environment. Not only that, but in pushing our children to learn more and faster, are we creating too much stress in their lives? They are not miniature adults, they are children who need play and the freedom to explore their own worlds.
So really, as parents I think we expect good behaviour from our children far too often. Children don’t need to scream in the grocery store, and they should learn good table manners. They also need freedom from rules to learn on their own the way our world works. Children need an environment of play where they are supervised without being guarded. They need their secret giggles and even the odd playground fight to learn how to get along. If we are always stepping in, when will they learn to do this on their own?
Children also need the freedom to be children, without hours of homework every night. They need to run around like hooligans in a playground so they can strengthen their bodies, and a good sound education to strengthen their minds. I believe in trying to do the best for our children, we have created an imbalance. Children still need play, even if we take away all forums for them to do so to a point that we equate rambuncious behaviour in inappropriate places with an ill-behaved child. The reality is that we have created a world where being rowdy is inappropriate everywhere.




May 30th, 2008 at 10:37 am
I couldn’t agree more… I try to make sure my little ones get to be “kids” as much as possible really. Schools are so worried about adhering to “standards” that they really ignore what the kids need a lot of times.
June 3rd, 2008 at 2:30 pm
fabulous! You echo a lot of my own thoughts. Unless a child is being really hurt then I make a point of not intervening in squabbles. A mother cat doesn’t separate two fighting kittens, so I think we can learn from that!
I feel that our kids are not given enough free playtime in school as well, so after a couple of years of the education system, we pulled our dd out of school. Now she’s running around all day long (apart from when she chooses to stick her head in a book!).
I have a post on this coming up soon as I learned this week that 76% of parents say their kids play outside for ONE hour a WEEK.
Great thoughts - thanks for a wonderful post.
mrs G x
June 4th, 2008 at 8:32 am
Dad: Thanks for your comment! My son will be starting kindergarten in a year, and I’m just wondering so much if they’ll push him too hard. Maybe most parents do worry about this too. But I see so much in my neices and nephews a hatred for learning. You can’t blame all of that on the schools, but if these kids are being pushed too hard, can you blame them?
Mrs. Green: Wow, one hour a week - I feel guilty if my son only gets out for an hour a day. Although I’m not surprised either. There was also a study linking the amount of time children spent in nature with a decrease in violence and increased overall IQ. I think it’s dangerous to get too detached from our world.
I really struggle to not intervene with my son, but I know it’s important that kids figure it out on their own. I certainly have a lot to learn, but I guess everything is a process.
Cheers!